Short-term Incentive

What Is a Merit Increase and Why Does It Matter?

Merit increases, sometimes referred to as merit pay, serve as a tangible recognition of an employee's exemplary performance, skills and dedication to the organization. Most often a salary adjustment, but sometimes other forms of compensation, merit pay increases exemplify an employer's commitment to valuing and incentivizing excellence. As a cornerstone of modern compensation strategies, merit increases play a pivotal role in bolstering employee satisfaction, motivating continued high achievement and fostering company loyalty.

Charlotte Kuhn
Head of Marketing

Defining Merit Increase

A merit increase, also called a merit raise, is a pay adjustment awarded to employees based on their performance, typically assessed through performance reviews. Unlike other types of raises, such as cost of living adjustments, a merit pay increase is earned by demonstrating exceptional contributions to the company.

Most companies grant merit increases annually, aligning with their performance review cycles. The appraisal process evaluates an employee's achievements, skills and overall impact on the company's success, with managers playing a pivotal role in the assessment. Once evaluations are complete, recommendations are typically reviewed by a compensation committee or human resource department, ensuring that pay raises align with both performance and budget considerations.

Merit increases serve multiple purposes: they recognize and reward dedication, motivate continued excellence and enhance employee morale. By tying pay to performance, companies foster a culture where employees feel valued, leading to heightened job satisfaction and productivity. In essence, merit increases are instrumental in promoting a culture of achievement, ensuring employees are recognized for their valuable contributions.

The Benefits of Merit Increases

Merit increases offer several benefits to both employees and employers. For employees, they provide recognition for their hard work and achievements, boosting their morale and motivation. Merit increases can also help employees feel valued and appreciated by the company, increasing employee engagement and job satisfaction.

From an employer's perspective, merit increases serve as a tool to retain top talent by rewarding high performers. By offering merit increases, companies can motivate employees to continue delivering exceptional results and contribute to the overall success of the business. This can lead to increased productivity and improved employee retention rates.

How Merit Increases Work

Merit increases are typically based on an employee's performance evaluation, which is typically conducted through a formal performance review process. During this process, managers assess an employee's performance against predetermined criteria and provide feedback on areas of strength and areas for improvement.

Based on the performance evaluation, managers determine the merit increase amount for each employee. This can be a percentage increase or a fixed dollar amount. The increase is then applied to the employee's base salary, effectively raising their overall compensation.

It is important to note that the amount of the merit increase can be influenced by various factors, such as the employee's performance rating, their position within the company and the overall budget available for merit increases.

How Merit Increases are Decided

Typically, the range for merit increases is determined by the board, often through its compensation committee, which assesses various factors before deciding on the appropriate percentage or range of percentages. One primary consideration is the overall company performance, which sets the tone for the total budget allocated for merit increases. 

Once this aggregate amount is decided, it is further distributed among employees based on individual performance, role significance and other internal metrics. It's common for companies to set their merit increase range in line with industry standards, economic conditions and company growth rate, ensuring that they remain competitive in attracting and retaining talent while also maintaining fiscal responsibility.

The process of determining merit pay for executives involves a careful evaluation of their performance and contributions. Throughout the performance evaluation period, executives are assessed based on their ability to achieve these goals, exceed expectations and contribute to the overall success of the organization. The evaluation process may involve input from various stakeholders, including supervisors, peers and subordinates.

Once the evaluation is complete, the executives' performance is taken into consideration in determining the merit raise. Factors such as the achievement of performance goals, leadership capabilities, impact on organizational outcomes and market benchmarks are typically considered.

Merit pay increases are typically reviewed and approved by a company’s board of directors and often have large-scale implications. For example, a 1% merit increase for a 200-person company with an average salary of $175,000, would cost $350,000. A 2% merit increase for a 3,000-person company with an average salary of $100,000 would cost $6M.

Implementing a Merit Increase Program

To effectively implement a merit increase program, companies should establish clear criteria for evaluating employee performance, as well as clearly identifying eligible employees. This can include setting specific goals and objectives for each employee, using key performance indicators to measure success, and conducting regular performance reviews. New employees are typically not eligible to partake in the merit pay program until some time with the company has elapsed.

Companies may already have a salary increase budget but may choose to specify a merit allocation or merit pool, specifically for merit-based raises.

It's crucial for companies to communicate the merit increase guidelines and process to employees in a transparent and fair manner. Employees should understand how their performance will be evaluated and the potential impact it can have on their compensation.

Another important aspect of implementing a merit increase program is ensuring consistency and fairness in the evaluation and reward process. Companies should strive to eliminate bias and ensure that merit increases are based solely on performance and contributions to the organization.

Merit Increase vs. Cost of Living Increase vs. Promotion Raise

While merit increases, cost of living increases and promotion raises all involve salary increases, there are key differences between them.

  • Merit Increase: Granted to employees based on their performance and contributions to the company. It is a way to reward high performing employees and incentivizes continued excellence.
  • Cost of Living Increase: A salary adjustment intended to account for inflation and the rising cost of living. It is typically given to all employees as a fixed percentage and is not tied to individual performance.
  • Promotion Raise: A salary increase that accompanies a promotion to a higher-level position. It is a way to reward employees who have taken on additional responsibilities and have been promoted to a more senior role within the company.

Best Practices for Offering Merit Increases

When offering merit increases, there are several best practices that companies can follow to ensure the process is fair and effective.

  • Establish clear performance criteria and communicate them to employees
  • Provide regular feedback and performance evaluations
  • Ensure consistency and fairness in the evaluation process
  • Allocate appropriate budget for merit increases
  • Consider individual employee circumstances when determining merit increase amounts
  • Recognize and reward both short-term and long-term contributions

The Importance of Merit Pay for Executives

A merit pay plan is of critical importance for executives as it serves as a tool to attract, motivate and retain top talent. Executives play a crucial role in the success of an organization, and merit based pay ensures that their efforts and contributions are recognized and rewarded accordingly. By offering competitive compensation packages that include merit pay, companies can incentivize employee performance, leading to improved organizational performance.

Real-world Examples

To illustrate the concept of merit increases, let's look at a couple of real-world examples.

  • Example 1: Company X has a performance evaluation cycle that takes place annually. Based on the evaluation results, employees who meet or exceed expectations are eligible for a merit increase. The increase is determined based on their performance rating and the overall budget available for merit increases. Employees receive the merit increase in their next pay cycle.
  • Example 2: Company Y has a quarterly performance evaluation system. At the end of each quarter, managers assess employee performance and provide feedback. Employees who consistently achieve outstanding results receive a merit increase, which is a percentage increase applied to their base salary. The merit increase is communicated to employees during a performance review meeting.

Potential Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

While merit increases can be beneficial, there are potential pitfalls that companies should be aware of and take steps to avoid.

One common pitfall is favoritism or bias in the evaluation process. To mitigate this, companies should establish clear evaluation criteria and provide training to managers on conducting fair and unbiased evaluations.

Another challenge is allocating an appropriate budget for merit increases. Companies should carefully consider their financial situation and allocate a sufficient budget to reward high performers. In cases where the budget is limited, alternative forms of recognition and rewards can be explored, such as non-monetary incentives or additional time off.

Lastly, companies should ensure that merit increases are aligned with their overall compensation strategy, market benchmarks and company goals. It is important to regularly review and adjust the merit increase system to remain competitive in attracting and retaining top talent.

Conclusion

A merit increase is typically a salary adjustment given to employees based on their performance and contributions. It is a way for employers to recognize and reward top performers, motivating them to continue delivering exceptional results. By implementing a fair and transparent merit increase system, companies can effectively recognize employee contributions, improve employee satisfaction, and retain valuable talent.